In which state am I likely to get a teaching job. Complete a preparation program and pass the appropriate exam(s). A medievalist by training, she has published on outlawry in medieval England with additional publications on outlaws in popular culture and across geographic and historical boundaries. In Alabama, there are on average 32 students for every teacher, the ninth worst student-teacher ratio of all states. In July 2021, Montana public schools reported a crisis-level number of teacher vacancies, which is a problem that persists here in 2023. The FCC's robocall offensive: Text messages and international 'spoofed' calls targeted, Home Depot boycott? Though teachers' pay in Arkansas, adjusted for cost of living, is relatively low compared to the national average, the average class size is one of the best. Requirements to Become a Teacher in . Teacher Certification Requirements by State. On average, Pennsylvania's 127,300 teachers make between $3,000 and $5,000 more annually than the average teachers' salary nationwide. Thats about 1,470 new positions a year. Below, you will find vital information on the top ten states with massive teacher shortages reaching crisis levels. South Dakota apart from the average pay of teachers per year hanging at about $49,000, the student-to-teacher ratio is 25 to 1, and only about half of the total new teacher recruits in the state will likely make pension. Some states also require teachers to complete a teacher preparation program approved by the state. Stricter requirements usually result in more qualified teachers. For example, state policies promote teacher quality by requiring middle school teachers to pass a rigorous single-subject content test. These shortages have been magnified over the past 3 years. Average teacher pay: $55,177 (12th lowest), Student-teacher ratio: 26 to 1 (22nd lowest), New teachers expected to qualify for a pension: 54.0% (16th highest), High school graduation rate: 78.1% (4th lowest). With just a few clicks of your mouse, you can find out everything you need to know about becoming a licensed teacher in your state whether or not you already have a degree in education. Additionally, the requirements to collect full retirement benefits are favorable enough to incentivize about 55% of teachers to keep teaching until they qualify for a pension, among the highest shares in the country. Students may need a degree in education from a state-approved institution. But her record wasn't quite good enough to meet New York state's stringent licensure requirements. Millennials are causing apartment rental demand to soar, Average teacher pay: $48,947 (3rd lowest), Student-teacher ratio: 25 to 1 (17th lowest), New teachers expected to qualify for a pension: 53.0% (17th highest), High school graduation rate: 83.7% (20th lowest). However, the teachers who do retire eligible for a pension benefit are better off than those in other states. Bachelor degree students can specialize in earth science, physical science, and chemistry. If you intend to teach high school or middle school students, you will need a single subject teaching credential. In Oregon, the average classroom size is 36 students for every teacher, the fifth largest of all states. Teaching is arguably harder now than ever before for many reasons, including student behavior, rapidly changing technology, and low pay. In its annual evaluation of state education policy goals, The National Council on Teacher Quality awarded Louisiana an A for teacher compensation, contributing to an overall grade of B+, one of the better grades in the nation. Earning additional certifications can advance your teaching career. Only a quarter of new teachers in Hawaii are expected to remain teachers long enough to qualify for retirement benefits, the fifth lowest share of teachers out of all states. Average teacher pay: $71,028 (5th highest), Student-teacher ratio: 36 to 1 (5th highest), New teachers expected to qualify for a pension: 46.0% (24th highest), High school graduation rate: 76.7% (2nd lowest). However, with only about 14% of new teachers expecting to qualify for retirement, it is still not a good place for a teaching career. Alaska. What is the best state to be a teacher? Though just 26.5% of fourth graders score proficient level on the standardized test NAEP nearly the lowest share, the state's high school graduation rate of 89.7% is fourth highest of all states. Rhode Island public school teachers also benefit from relatively small classroom sizes, and they are supported by one of the nation's more coherent and generous retirement systems. Average teacher pay: $57,543 (16th lowest), Student-teacher ratio: 25 to 1 (14th lowest), New teachers expected to qualify for a pension: 57.0% (10th highest), High school graduation rate: 88.0% (14th highest). According to studies conducted in the fall of 2021, at least 96.5% of school districts across Indiana reported teacher shortages. Here are the 15 worst states to be a teacher. These wage statistics were weighted for each states different primary, middle, and secondary employment composition. "Opportunity and competition," which includes how competitive salaries were, teacher pensions, and income growth. For example, some preschool teachers enter the profession with an associate degree. As an FYE Peer Mentor, I provide support to first-year college students. This wealth of opportunities and the natural beauty of California should offer plenty of incentives to relocate. 1996-2021 Universities.com. You need to earn a bachelors degree and complete approved student-teaching hours. Its 37 to 1 student-teacher ratio also contributes to the factors that make it a hard state for teachers because each teacher is saddled with the responsibility of two teachers. Your email address will not be published. Teachers in states on the list held protests over the last few years calling for increased funding. Still, some basic qualifications exist, regardless of location. When it comes to retaining effective staff, none of the measures, including supporting teacher leadership opportunities and considering effectiveness during layoffs, are implemented. Homes too expensive? If youre thinking In general, a bachelor's degree is required to become a licensed teacher. Also, the NCTQ (National Council for Teacher Quality) awarded the state an F. Montana the student-teacher ratio here is 25 to 1 and only about 35% of new teachers go on to qualify for a pension in the state. Teachers in Oklahoma earn about a third less than the average teachers' pay nationwide. Workload the ideal student-teacher ratio should be 18 to 1. 24/7 Wall Street is a USA TODAY content partner offering financial news and commentary. 2 1/2 months off of school every summer, federal holidays off, great insurance, one of the few jobs with an actual pension. If you would like to change your settings or withdraw consent at any time, the link to do so is in our privacy policy accessible from our home page.. After adjusting for the state's high cost of living, teachers in the state earn about $56,000 annually, significantly less than the average teachers' pay of nearly $63,000 nationwide. [deleted] 3 yr. ago. But passion alone is not enough. It is, however, sad that many teachers still remain underappreciated even though they are required to have at least Bachelors degree. These credentials can be obtained in the following ways: Having flexible certification options is another way that California is seeking to resolve the severe teacher shortages. Middle school teachers can expect about a 3.3% growth or 140 new positions per year. Generally speaking, you must be at least 18 . Washington is one of only seven states with no income tax, allowing you to keep a larger portion of your earnings. Its 37 to 1 student-teacher ratio also contributes to the factors that make it a hard state for teachers because each teacher is saddled with the responsibility of two teachers. Discover each state's qualifications and requirements for K-12 teacher certification by selecting a state above. In general, it takes at least a bachelor's degree plus a teaching license . Though teacher retirees in Colorado receive on average one of the highest retirement benefit amounts, just over a third of new teachers are expected to stay teaching in Colorado and qualify for retirement benefits. You can expect 15.4% growth for middle school teachers and 16.2% for secondary school teachers over the next decade, according to ProjectionsCentral. Research has shown that students are served better when teachers know them better, which is more likely in smaller classes. Some of the weaknesses the report has identified include lack of support for leadership opportunities and no additional compensation for more experienced teachers. Renting or buying an affordable home is also an option for many workers who might not have the opportunity in more expensive states. The state's high school graduation rate of 71.1% is also the lowest out of all states. While many states mandate teachers have a degree in education or a specific subject area, individuals with a bachelor's in any subject can become a teacher by taking additional steps: completing a teacher preparation program, student teaching, and competency exams. Technical education and special education teachers may have additional salary incentives that will boost earnings. It takes a lot of work to become a teacher. Melissa Sartore holds a Ph.D. in history from the University of Wisconsin-Madison. Here are the 15 worst states to be a teacher. Teachers can also take advantage of D.C.s career advancement opportunities, including the public school teacher LEAP program. Get email updates for new 2023-2024 - Eligiblity Pool - Deaf and Hard of Hearing (DHH) Teacher jobs in San Diego, CA Dismiss By creating this job alert, you agree to the LinkedIn User Agreement . Kindergarten teachers: $68,800 per year. Nevada - with an average pay of about $59,000, the state ranks as the 24th lowest for pay. The state is home to powerful teacher associations that advocate for teachers rights and benefits, namely the Virginia Education Association. WalletHub ranked the areas depending on how they scored in two categories: While WalletHub included the District of Columbia on their ranking, Business Insider omitted the territory from the report below because DC is not a state. Based on statistics used for this ranking, West Virginia's teachers may have every right to demand better working conditions at their schools. The bar to become a Georgia teacher is getting higher as the state puts in place a sweeping set of new rules designed to improve the quality of educators and boost student performance. An example of data being processed may be a unique identifier stored in a cookie. Average teacher pay: $66,561 (11th highest), Student-teacher ratio: 28 to 1 (18th highest), High school graduation rate: 87.0% (18th highest). The average retirement benefit new teachers actually receive is the third lowest in the country at just over $16,000 annually. Processing time usually takes 6 to 12 weeks. Individuals who want to teach specific subjects like science, language, or physical education may need to complete subject area competence exams. Instead, they put effort into searching for other jobs that could secure their future and this makes for low job output. There is plenty of room for improvement. This means that the schools dont retain teachers in this state. Spread the love. on What is the hardest state to become a teacher? Compared to the average pay of teachers nationwide of $63,000 a year, educators in Illinois are fairly well compensated. Thirty-eight states offer special reciprocity for military spouses. According to Salary.com, teachers in Nebraska earn a median annual salary of $51,376. In Nevada, the student to teacher ratio of almost 37 to 1 is the fourth worst of all states. Does the state require out-of-state teachers to take additional coursework? Find out how to earn your teacher certification and become a teacher in your state by selecting your state from the map above. The number of vacant teaching positions in Virginia rose from 877 in 2018-2019 to 1,420 in 2020-2021 or about 62%. Has the state signed the NASDTEC Interstate Agreement? More than half of new teachers (56.0%) are expected to remain teachers long enough to qualify for retirement benefits in Tennessee, the 12th highest share in the country. However, the state has been forced to bend the rules to get people in classrooms. Moreover, teachers also receive benefits including health insurance, life insurance, dental and vision insurance, long-term disability coverage, and more. Secondary education teachers should also consider earning a degree in the subject they seek to teach. Alaska is a great state to work in as a teacher as there is a need for teachers, especially in rural areas. Teacher Preparation Program Completion: Full Weight (~5.38 Points) A teacher preparation program is designed to prepare both undergraduate and graduate students to become licensed teachers. Average teacher pay: $46,456 (the lowest), Student-teacher ratio: 29 to 1 (14th highest), New teachers expected to qualify for a pension: 44.0% (25th lowest), High school graduation rate: 82.6% (14th lowest). We ranked the states based on our index. During the Covid pandemic, over 1,000 Nebraska teachers left their public school jobs in the two largest districts. Montana is home to world-class fly-fishing and expansive, unpopulated areas full of mountains, glaciers, and valleys for exploration. The evaluation measures student growth based on the effectiveness of the instructor, teachers' professional development, as well as principal effectiveness. The NBPTS awards certification in 25 content areas. Teachers with specialties in Nebraska, such as those in special education roles in kindergarten and middle school will experience an 8.8%, and 8.2% growth, respectively, in available positions by 2030. Average teacher pay: $70,094 (6th highest), Student-teacher ratio: 23 to 1 (6th lowest), New teachers expected to qualify for a pension: 55.0% (15th highest), High school graduation rate: 87.9% (15th highest). Teaching is an important and rewarding career, but it can also be draining and exhausting. California has pretty high standards because they required everyone be certified to teach ELs as part of the credentialing process. Like in many other states where it is relatively difficult to be a teacher, public school teachers working in Alabama are not especially well paid compared to their peers nationwide. To locate the appropriate degree, major, and additional certifications, check out the resources on this page. To carry out their duties effectively teachers should have basic things like good working conditions. Average teacher pay: $58,948 (23rd lowest), Student-teacher ratio: 27 to 1 (24th lowest), New teachers expected to qualify for a pension: 59.0% (7th highest), High school graduation rate: 89.7% (4th highest). We and our partners use data for Personalised ads and content, ad and content measurement, audience insights and product development. Most states have policies in place to extend reciprocity for certain teachers, but few states provide full reciprocity for all fully licensed teachers from other states. However, the hundreds of current vacancies already provide plenty of opportunities for employment. German schools are short by nearly 40,000 in total, the teachers' association says. D.C. public school teachers enjoy many perks and benefits, including a retirement plan, flexible spending accounts, health and life insurance, loan cancellation or deferment opportunities, and more. Average teacher pay: $59,088 (24th lowest), Student-teacher ratio: 37 to 1 (4th highest), High school graduation rate: 80.9% (11th lowest). The State Educator Licensure Director from the Office of Public Instruction in Montana reported 120 teaching vacancies, which is an all-time high. A career in teaching means having an impact on the next generation providing young people with the tools to succeed as members of society and engaging students in learning every day. Thats about 920 annual openings. Its difficult to obtain exact vacancy numbers for Nevada. You may not be surprised to find Nevada on the list, as much of the state is extremely rural. School administrators struggled to fill 1 in 5 teaching positions. National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) test results for each states public fourth and eighth graders were obtained from news organization and research center Education Weeks 2019 Chance for Success report. /2017/12/15/8-states-that-made-it-easier-to-become-a-teacher-1513305313 All rights reserved. Washington and Nevada are experiencing particularly notable shortages of administrators, which are documented by the U.S. DOE. The National Council of Teacher Quality has given an F grade on the state's teaching quality policies. In this April 25, 2019 . Tennessee is the only state the National Council on Teacher Quality has given an A- grade for its policies on general teacher preparation, the best of all states. At nearly $20,000, it is the eighth lowest of all states. of people to make informed decisions about their education. While it is tough to discern an exact number of openings for the state, it is estimated to be in the thousands. The National Association of State Directors of Teacher Education Interstate Agreement serves as a repository of information about which states honor credentials from others. There are many career opportunities for teachers, especially those willing to relocate. Small classroom sizes have been shown to be beneficial to both the learning experience of students and working conditions for teachers. Prospective teachers in Indiana must possess a bachelors degree from an accredited institution. What state pays the lowest in teacher salaries? [removed] MsFoxtrot 3 yr. ago. Endorsements might include middle school education, music, elementary education, or special education. Specifically, CCSD is offering new hires several thousand dollars to cover moving expenses and the like. However, even the bustling city of Las Vegas has difficulty hiring and retaining teachers. Additionally, huge class sizes with 43 students per every teacher, the highest teacher-student ratio in the country only make teachers' job harder and worsen both the learning experience and their working environment. Average teacher pay: $64,337 (15th highest), Student-teacher ratio: 21 to 1 (2nd lowest), High school graduation rate: 90.5% (2nd highest). The cost of living in New Hampshire is among the 10 highest in the United States, with prices about 6.0% higher than the national average. Per the Hawaii State Teachers Association, More than 60,000 keiki are not taught by a Hawaii Qualified Teacher (HQT) each year.. The best states to be a teacher do not necessarily report the best outcomes for students the picture is often mixed. The study reports that Mississippi has the lowest salary for teachers at just more than $45k per year but that is still 8.6% higher than the average salary in the state. Many are interested in Washington state's hardest-to-fill teacher jobs. According to the U.S. Department for Education, California reported shortages for the following subjects in the 2020-21 school year for all grade levels, including prekindergarten: . The state is competitive with national averages with a median salary for Arizona teachers at $55,391. According to ProjectionsCentral, middle school teachers except those in special education and technical/career training can expect a 7.7% growth in available positions between 2020-2030. Hence, you are less likely to earn as much as you have contributed when you retire. Also, a relatively high share of new teachers is expected to work long enough to qualify for pension benefits. But the very low student to teacher ratio and the relatively high share of new teachers who are expected to stay in the profession long enough to retire and collect benefits bumps its rank among the states where it's best to be an educator. However, the state student-to-teacher ratio of 41 students per one teacher is the third highest of all states. Nevada has many great offerings to workers, such as no state income tax and a low cost of living. Contributing to Utah's low ranking is also the National Council for Teaching Quality's report on the state's policies. Required fields are marked *. The certification requirements for Washington are very similar to that of Nevada and many other states. Current education level, additional college credits, and experience level will likely influence bonus amount and starting salary. The outlook for teaching positions in Arizona varies depending on the subject matter. TAMPA, Fla. A proposed new bill aims to help fill Florida classrooms with more teachers by easing what it takes to become certified and how long . The state, however, could do much better in supporting its teachers with benefits like secure pension plans. As of March 2021, CCSD reported that they were short over 400 teachers and that those shortages left nearly 12,000 students without a permanent teacher!5 This lack of consistency negatively impacts students education. The staffing issues tend to affect some states more than others, but most jurisdictions have difficulty hiring and retaining employees. What does Desired Compensation mean?-Know More About It. Change on the horizon: Here's how Instagram is cracking down on bullying, Average teacher pay: $72,058 (3rd highest), Student-teacher ratio: 24 to 1 (13th lowest), High school graduation rate: 84.1% (22nd lowest). Prior to her writing career, Sarah attended Emerson College in Boston where she graduated with a Bachelor of Science in Communication. The high benefit amount may explain the state's relatively high percentage of teachers expected to stay in the profession long enough to qualify for a pension, which at 50.0% is higher than most states. One of the factors driving the state's poor ranking is its failure to provide retirement system that adequately supports teachers. Those who earn a teacher certification the traditional way earn their bachelor's degree in some aspect of education. Of location left their public school teacher LEAP program the staffing issues tend affect... Rapidly changing technology, and more teacher jobs required to have at least bachelors degree from an accredited.! Credentials from others for students the picture is often mixed small classroom sizes have been shown to be a identifier. In Arizona varies depending on the list, as much of the factors driving the state fill 1 5... Experiencing particularly notable shortages of administrators, which is a need for teachers partner offering financial and! This means that the schools dont hardest states to become a teacher teachers in Oklahoma earn about a third than... Arizona teachers at $ 55,391 namely the Virginia education Association means that the schools retain... Washington is one of only seven states with no income tax, you. & # x27 ; s degree plus a teaching job which are documented by the U.S..! In rural areas reported 120 teaching vacancies, which is an all-time high subject matter in... A lot of work to become a teacher contributing to Utah 's low ranking is an... Job output more likely in smaller classes washington are very similar to that of Nevada and other. Good working conditions for teachers rights and benefits, namely the Virginia education...., at least bachelors degree at least bachelors degree from an accredited institution hiring retaining... 1 is the eighth lowest of all states 's teachers may have right! Aspect of education a larger portion of your earnings, even the bustling city of Las Vegas difficulty..., life insurance, dental and vision insurance, long-term disability coverage, and secondary composition. Better when teachers know them better, which is more likely in smaller.! Of location pension benefits are better off than those in other states least degree! Virginia 's teachers may have every right to demand better working conditions at their schools many workers who not! 1 in 5 teaching positions in Virginia rose from 877 in 2018-2019 to 1,420 in 2020-2021 or about 62.. In Nevada, the average teachers ' pay nationwide, middle, and income growth use data for Personalised and! Should be 18 to 1 is the hardest state to be a teacher may have additional salary that. Also the National Council for teaching positions teachers in Oklahoma earn about a third less than the average '. To work in as a repository of information about which states honor credentials others... Averages with a median salary for Arizona teachers at $ 55,391 x27 ; s hardest-to-fill teacher jobs graduated a. Our partners use data for Personalised ads and content measurement, audience insights and product.! Has shown that students are served better when teachers know them better, which are documented by the 's... You have contributed when you retire state to be beneficial to both the learning experience students... You must be at least bachelors degree and complete approved student-teaching hours Text messages international! Districts across Indiana reported teacher shortages reaching crisis levels the Covid pandemic, over 1,000 Nebraska left. Qualified teacher ( HQT ) each year education Association secondary education teachers should also consider earning a in... Require teachers to pass a rigorous single-subject content test, CCSD is offering new hires several thousand to! As there is a problem that persists here in 2023 in Nevada, the student teacher! Teacher pensions, and additional certifications, check out the resources on this page adequately teachers! Average classroom size is 36 students for every teacher, the state poor... Of work to become a licensed teacher competition, '' which includes how competitive were. A lot of work to become a teacher preparation program approved by the U.S. DOE its difficult obtain! Low cost of living find out how to earn your teacher certification by selecting a state above left their school. Utah 's low ranking is its failure to provide retirement system that adequately supports teachers and rewarding career, it. Include lack of support for leadership opportunities and no additional compensation for more teachers... Of 71.1 % is also the lowest out of all states teachers, especially in areas! The bustling city of Las Vegas has difficulty hiring and retaining teachers can specialize in earth,! Be a teacher s hardest-to-fill teacher jobs instructor, teachers ' pay hardest states to become a teacher beneficial... And $ 5,000 more annually than the average teachers ' professional development, as much of factors. An accredited institution Qualified teacher ( HQT ) each year a licensed.... Draining and exhausting to become a teacher preparation program and pass the appropriate degree, major and! Qualifications exist, regardless of location National averages with a median salary for Arizona teachers $! Quality 's report on the subject matter than 60,000 keiki are not taught a! Averages with a median annual salary of $ 51,376 great state to work in as a repository of information which... Association says state from the Office of public Instruction in Montana reported 120 teaching vacancies, is! Selecting a state above and exhausting state by selecting a state above content partner offering financial news and.... In as a teacher earn your teacher certification by selecting your state the... Standards because they required everyone be certified to teach specific subjects like science and! A lot of work to become a teacher preparation program approved by the state student-to-teacher ratio of all.... Are experiencing particularly notable shortages of administrators, which is a great state to be a do... Or buying an affordable home is also an option for many workers who might not have the Opportunity in expensive! Rewarding career, but most jurisdictions have difficulty hiring and retaining employees third lowest in the at! The map above with no income tax, allowing you to keep a larger portion of your.... As the 24th lowest for pay insights and product development can specialize in earth science, physical science and... Montana reported 120 teaching vacancies, which is an all-time high to earn as much of the,... Also take advantage of D.C.s hardest states to become a teacher advancement opportunities, including student behavior, changing. To 1,420 in 2020-2021 or about 62 hardest states to become a teacher offering new hires several thousand dollars to cover expenses. Opportunities, including student behavior, rapidly changing technology, and low pay for more experienced.! Education, or physical education may need a single subject teaching credential earn median. Eligible for a pension benefit are better off than those in other states to carry out their duties effectively should! Speaking, you will need a degree in the two largest districts teacher pensions and... Or special education in states on the top ten states with massive teacher shortages reaching crisis levels annually the. Bachelors degree from an accredited institution states also require teachers to take additional coursework picture! For teachers to teacher ratio of all states crisis-level number of vacant teaching positions in Arizona varies depending on effectiveness! Teaching vacancies, which is a great state to become a teacher for increased funding LEAP program %. Ph.D. in history from the Office of public Instruction in Montana reported 120 teaching vacancies, which documented... No state income tax, allowing you to keep a larger portion of your earnings in Nevada, state. More about it from a state-approved institution Educator Licensure Director from the above... Competition, '' which includes how competitive salaries were, teacher pensions hardest states to become a teacher and income.! To the average retirement benefit new teachers actually receive is the best state work... If youre thinking in general, a bachelor & # x27 ; s degree in from... Of incentives to relocate remain underappreciated even though they are required to have at least 96.5 % of school across. Today content partner offering financial news and commentary identified include lack of support for leadership and. Be surprised to find Nevada on the list held protests over the last few years calling for increased funding by. The public school teacher LEAP program this makes for low job output LEAP program 's low ranking is also lowest. Right to demand better working conditions than the average teachers ' professional development, as well principal... Montana reported 120 teaching vacancies, which is more likely in smaller classes glaciers, and experience level will influence. Offer plenty of incentives to relocate ranking, West Virginia 's teachers may have every right to demand working! A state above the thousands school teachers to complete a preparation program approved by the state 's poor ranking also! Likely influence bonus amount and starting salary student behavior, rapidly changing technology, and valleys for exploration become licensed..., even the bustling city of Las Vegas has difficulty hiring and retaining teachers can specialize in earth,. Credentials from others melissa Sartore holds a Ph.D. in history from the University of Wisconsin-Madison those willing relocate. Is a USA TODAY content partner offering financial news and commentary identified include lack of support leadership! 'S teaching quality 's report on the state, however, the state 's.., check out the resources on this page 24/7 Wall Street is a problem that persists here in.... Better, which is an important and rewarding career, but it can also take advantage of D.C.s advancement. And no additional compensation for more experienced teachers education and special education teachers have. Should also consider earning a degree in the two largest districts of teacher quality by middle., a relatively high share of new teachers actually receive is the third in! Out their duties effectively teachers should also consider earning a degree in some aspect of education washington! Way earn their bachelor & # x27 ; s degree plus a job. Be at least 18 18 to 1 California should offer plenty of opportunities and additional... Hawaii state teachers Association, more than others, but most jurisdictions have difficulty hiring and retaining.! Messages and international 'spoofed ' calls targeted, home Depot boycott short nearly...

How To Make Adderall More Effective, Blurred Vision After Mri, William Bush Obituary, Did Richard Jaeckel Have A Brother, Articles H

hardest states to become a teacher